There was nothing worth watching on tv last night, and for some strange reason when I went to turn off the computer I found myself creating a spreadsheet instead.
You see, a question in among the comments of the Come On Knitpicks petition site had been niggling at me. If we do have plenty of alternatives to Knitpicks yarns here in Australia, what are they?
To work that out, a knitter would have to actually see the yarns. So I went over to the Knitpicks site to see if they had a shade card. They do. They have one for every yarn except those you dye yourself (that’s 26 yarns) and you have to buy them . For US$1.99 each. It would cost you A$65.71 to get samples of KP’s entire range!
When you consider that Bendigo Woollen Mills sends out shade cards for free, Knitpicks are looking a bit ‘cheap’ rather than cheap. From what I recall, I got a free shade card from Nundle as well (but I can’t find any comfirmation of whether they are or not on their site, so don’t quote me on that).
Next I decided to look at prices. It’s easy to get excited by $1.99 yarn on the Knitpicks site, but they’re in US dollars, and for 50 gram balls mostly. So I typed in the specs for Knitpicks yarns into a spreadsheet, including name, composition, weight, number of colours available, machine washable or not, and price. Then I started matching up Bendigo yarns to similar Knitpicks ones (I started with Bendigo because they have the largest range I know of for an independant Aussie yarn manufacturer) and all sorts of interesting information came out.
I found Bendigo yarns are often cheaper than Knitpicks. And they usually come in more colours.
Of course, Bendigo don’t make as wide a range of yarns as Knitpicks. They make the essentials – 100% wool in a range of weights in both machine washable and not, some cotton, some alpaca, and a couple of blends. They also sell the yarn in 200gram balls or skeins, which is economical if you want one or a couple of colours, but not if you wanted to buy lots of small amounts to make a complicated intarsia. Then it’s going to cost you a lot and you’ll have lots of leftovers.
Comparisons by weight:
Laceweight: Knitpicks has five kinds, one plain, three in 8 colours and one in 12. Bendy Classic in 2 or 3ply could replace the plain and 100% merino versions, and is also machine washable, comes in 36 solid colours, and is cheaper.
Fingering/4ply: KP has 11 kinds, four plain for dyeing. Most have only a small range of colours, but the 100% peruvian wool comes in 30 colours (but isn’t machine washable so obviously isn’t meant for socks). The mashine washable yarn comes in 14 colours.
This is where Bendigo yarns fail. You could use their Baby Wool, but it comes in only 8 pathetic pastels. However, you could also use their Colonial 5ply, or better still, their Classic 5ply, which is machine washable. Both come in 36 colours. But if you’re after a bit of nylon for better wearing, forget it. Still, if it’s a choice between machine washable and nylon content, I’ll go for the former first. After all, my socks will never wear out if I don’t wear them because I can’t be bothered handwashing them.
For cotton socks, there’s a Cotton 4ply, which isn’t really elastic enough for socks (I’ve tried it). Unfortunately Bendigo Harmony, which is a wool/cotton/lycra blend, only comes in 8ply.
Bendigo really needs to put out a good basic sock wool.
Sportweight/5ply: KP has 5 kinds, none machine washable except the cotton and the hand painted sock yarn. Bendigo Colonial 5ply could replace the non mw KP, and they have an advantage over KP in having the machine washable version – Classic 5ply. Both are cheaper than KP sportweight wool.
DK/8ply: This category left me stunned. KP has only 5 kinds of DK, and the only one that is machine washable is the cotton! Bendigo Classic, Colonial, Rustic, Harmony, Cotton and Alpaca, plus Nundle 8ply (and Nundle have 30 great colours), make for a much larger range – with a bigger range of colours, than KPs does in this category. While the Bendigo cottons are a little dearer than the KP cotton, the Classic, Colonial, Rustic and Alpaca beat KP prices.
Worsted/10ply: More than half of KP yarns are aran weight to super bulky. I suspect either they’re catering to the kind of knitter who wants a quick, thick knit… or maybe their worsted is actually closer to our 8ply than their DK is. A number of these yarns are novelty yarns, which I won’t bother trying to find a match for. There are 9 KP yarns in the worsted category. For an alternative, Bendigo Colonial comes in a Aran weight, but only in 8 of their 36 colours, but is cheaper than similar KP arans. Also, Nundle’s 8ply is thicker than usual, and could probably do for aran weight knits.
Bulky/12ply: KP has 10 varieties, some novelty. For a good local 12ply 100% wool yarn, Bendigo has Classic and Rustic – and Nundle also does 12ply that’s cheaper than the Bendy!
Super Bulky: KP has three, but they’re a bit ‘novelty’. Nundle Woollen Mills does a chunky 20 ply in many fabulous colours.
Other observations: Knitpicks doesn’t have any mohair yarns. Since I don’t like mohair much, I’m hardly bothered by that. But I do wonder why not. Instead they have a lot of blends containing alpaca.
It is the blends that require more research to find comparable yarns at comparable prices. I expect I’d find lots of similar blends made by Naturally, the New Zealand yarn manufacturer. Price might be a let down there, however. Naturally might make beautiful yarns, but not at bargain prices.
Knitpicks “Bare” yarns, meant for you to dye yourself, come in 100 gram lots, so they’re exceptionally cheap, but in laceweight and DK the difference in price to similiar Bendy yarns is smaller, so compare before you buy.
Overall, I can see that Knitpicks is catering to quite a different market than Bendigo, shown by the variety of sock yarns and bulky yarns, and blends. Bendigo makes an economical and reliable alternative if you want something more standard, like a machine washable 5ply, 8ply, etc. They have been sending me (free!) shade cards for blends – an alpaca/wool and wool/mohair/alpaca/angora blend – but these weren’t on the latest price list so maybe they didn’t generate enough sales.
So, to sum up, if you’re after a good sturdy plain yarn look into Bendigo and Nundle Woollen Mill’s range and prices. Don’t be fooled by prices that seem cheap because they’re in US dollars and for smaller balls and skeins.
If you’re after something fancier – blends and fancy dye jobs – also do your sums. It may be that by the time you have your order posted to a friend in the US or Canada, then add to that cost the price of postage to Australia, it may be cheaper to buy higher priced yarn from shops that mail to Australia.
Shops that don’t treat Australia like a third world country.